ledies22

what is the best remake?

We also dont need to smear every thread with this. This is about Sisley not CMW.

Pete Carroll yes. Jim Harbaugh no. He served his time, and faced the repercussions. He is moving on from something that i would say did him dirty. He is like the ornery kid in class that gets in trouble all of the time that other kids get away with.

i agree. @KoB2011 go back to the green letter K lol

You're right comparing stuff is stupid. ill drop it.

I think you're off base here. there is literally a fire coach Woodson thread on here. This is not some "imbecile" on twitter. Who pays for the firing of coaches? Its the boosters. Why do the boosters do that? because they are fans. No one is saying it is the fault and only the fault of the fans, but to act like they don't have anything to do with it is madness.

is it easier though? There is an argument that it is harder today. NIL, and the transfer market levels the playing field no? Yes it is easier to turn around in a year, but it is just as easy to go the other direction with the portal. the street goes both ways. Ultimately the coach is judged based on results... record and tournament. It doesn't need to get any more complicated than that. Would have IU fans ran said coach out of town based on results?

more than Cig?

I think i would care more if he wasn't making the effort to recruit whether he plans on being here or not.

Joey Mauler 7th of the JAWS list. Sorry, that was a bad joke. I will see myself out.

It would be easier to just look at the records and tournament results. If we consider the NIL and transfer portal, then we would have to consider the adding of the three point line, the expansion of the tournament, and various other changes which would be hard to factor.

I don’t think there is a lot of explanation needed. You look at a coach’s record and results in terms of post season, and see at what point would IU fans eat them alive and have them fired or at least try and make fire x coach as a topic thread.

it is indeed. I went through almost 15 coaches with this exercise and the only one I could say (not confidently) was Bill Self at Kansas. Dan Hurley, K, Izzo, Dusty May, Painter, Pearl, Scott Drew

haha idk how i missed this. pure gold.

for me it's not the secondary head to chest, it's the intentional head butt prior, that happened to miss. Followed by the insignificant contact. If we are going to come one here and blame XJ for his actions and leave the Rutgers kid off scot free, we have to do the same in this situation, no? I realize XJ's actions were a lot worse but so was the reaction from Rutgers. Same here, the head butt wasn't terrible, but the reaction was also nothingness.

We take players numbers and stats at face value all of the time, why can't we do the same for coaches and their records/results?

Correct, but on the other side, would you rather have pissed off fans or apathetic fans. I would prefer the former. I wish there was a better way to express that I guess.... idk.

they do, but not to the extent. I think our overreaction at times exacerbates the issue. Coach Cal seems to have made it through, at least temporarily. But I would put us up there with Kentucky in terms of overreaction and temperamental fan bases. But i dont think any other major program has experienced what we have in the last 20 years. I think you can go down the list of every coach, and say they would not have lasted here in the current environment based on their results.

Thats the good side of IU fans.... interactive, engaged, following coaches, teams, and (probably) most important recruits/players. The bad side.... as much as I hate the negativity, I love this board because most people can have a discussion with differing opinions. I believe the issue lies outside of this board and on social media. with those 1 million followers you have a greater percentage of fans posting things. A greater percentage of those are negative currently. It's not just that they are negative. It's the message. It's how it is delivered. Everyone has a voice there. I mean look at Dan Jockitch. That doesn't go unnoticed. I am not sure how big of an issue it is, but if I was Liam McNeeley, I would have some concerns.

when it's this bad, its hard for me to dogpile on one aspect. there is plenty of blame to go around.

Yah, that's not what they are talking about.

It's like Minnesota fans being pissed about not having as much basketball money as IU. some people will b**** just to b****. You cant reason with the unreasonable.

weren't you the one that said the reaction should never be punishable after the XJ incident?

i wouldn't expect it with all of the talent they have. yah, not really one to follow closely yet, but CMW is building long term relationships..... if he is still around.

Offered 6-5" 247 4 star, 5 star composite. combo guard at Montverde